I like to think I'm a professional, constantly learning, coaching and teaching agile team member who specialises in Testing and people.
I'm a active member of the Testing community, I host the London Tester Gathering and speak at conferences.
We didn't spend time thinking through exactly what we wanted to achieve, or how we'd know if we were getting there.
SpecFlow, however, was shiny and new and we were still working on how exactly we were going to use automation in testing.
We were lucky that people with the business knowledge were available.
We were unlucky in that the people with business knowledge were offsite most of the time.
We decided to trial BDD, which was driven by the tool and by the 'Software makers', which at the time did not include anybody from the business.
This (now) seems wrong and didn't work as effectively as it could have.
I have no evidence to back this up, but I believe that having the business suggest the idea of BDD would change the approach completely.
BDD is about focusing on collaboration, not focusing on a tool.
You can work with BDD without ever using automation and receive plenty of value.
In-some cases you'll be better off as you won't get lost in the tool and focus on the collaboration.
Collaboration is the key and point.
So, there we were; Giving it, Whening it and Thening like mad.
Mostly written (solely) by the Business Analysts and therefore bypassing a shared understanding and attempting to share one person's understanding.
Here's an example:
Scenario: Display ‘Insurer Selection’ screen
Given that Insurer selection screen has been invoked When the Insurer selection UI is rendered Then the ‘Insurer Selection’ page is displayed And the ‘Risk Variation Name’ field is displayed And the ‘Risk Variation Name’ field is selected And the ‘Customer Name’ is displayed And only breadcrumb ‘Select Insurer’ is displayed And all insurers setup in the system for the policy type are displayed And all insurers setup in the system for the policy type are not selected And the ‘Next’ button is disabled
We were learning.
We hadn't quite grasped yet that the how wasn't important, it's the what that is important.